By using this website, you agree to our use of cookies to enhance your experience.
We have 1 guests online 
Sign up

Employment tribunal system 'failing'

Friday 15th April 2011
The employment tribunal system is failing businesses and individuals, the CBI believes.

It is meant to offer claimants and companies informal, quick and cost-effective judgements, but instead the system is slow, legalistic and antagonistic.

In its submission to the Government’s Resolving Workplace Disputes consultation, the CBI called for a package of measures to speed up the tribunal system, reduce costs for both sides, and make the system fairer.

Katja Hall, CBI Chief Policy Director, said: "It’s always regrettable when the relationship between employer and employee breaks down to the point where a tribunal claim is made.

"But when this happens, both sides deserve a system that is consistent, quick and keeps legal costs to a minimum. Instead, we are saddled with a tribunal system that is expensive, stressful and time-consuming for all parties.

"Surely it’s in everyone’s interests for cases with merit to be heard quickly and settled, while weak claims are swiftly identified and weeded out. We’d like to see more workplace disputes being resolved before they reach tribunal."

With a 173% rise in claims since 2005, and an ever-increasing claims backlog, the CBI is calling for:

* Action to weed out weak claims
The CBI calls for a package of measures designed to prevent weak claims. This includes making sure people are aware of what they could achieve to avoid unrealistic expectations. In addition, the CBI also calls on the Government to introduce a proportionate fee per claim designed to ensure that only reasonable claims are brought. Fees should never be a barrier to justice, but should be proportionate and refundable on success;

* Measures to encourage settlement at an early stage
A fair settlement early in a case is a better outcome for all parties. A formal system for making offers to settle, and advising the tribunal when a reasonable offer has been turned down, should be put in place. Compromise agreements, where an employer and employee agree on a deal to end an employment relationship by mutual consent without using the tribunal system, are inherently fair. But the legal process around them has become unnecessarily complicated and expensive. The Government should make compromise agreements much easier to use;

* Using employment tribunal league tables to improve efficiency and consistency
Where a case reaches tribunal, employers and claimants have a right to expect consistency and efficient handling of the case. This includes reducing unnecessary documentation and keeping to the timetable set out for judgements. Showing how different regions and individual judges perform against these standards will encourage best practice and greater efficiency. The Tribunals Service currently gathers national-level data, but no regional breakdown is available. A transparent mechanism which shows how the system is working across the country would restore credibility.

Have your say on this story using the comment section below

Mike Jones

blog comments powered by Disqus
View Comments

(3) Comments | Report Abuse

Added by Forever on 2011-07-04 02:11:52

Dude, right on there botrher.
Added by Barbara on 2011-04-15 05:06:04

A number of so called weak claims come before the tribunals because of the disgraceful way in which employers treat employees. Employment practices when it comes to dealing with complaints are, in my opinion, truly outdated in this country and especially in isolated regions like Northern Ireland. Modernise these and you will lessen the burden of the tribunals
Added by Barry on 2011-04-15 04:30:43


One, that hopeless cases are not weeeded out by Proper Case Management by the Chairmen of Tribunals

Two, the continued lamentable failure by Tribunal Chairmen to strike out cases where one or other party fails to comply with Directions or Orders, for whatever reason

The need to have far more telephone Conferences and Cse Management Conferences

If these tthree gross failures were addressed the whole system would speed up gereat and at less cost
If you have any questions or suggestions about this article or our news section, please don't hesitate to contact us.

Editorial Contact Details - Conor Shilling
0845 672 6000
Related News Stories
Most Read News Stories